Have you heard? Women’s happiness levels have been declining since 1972. We get sadder as we age. The one thing most depressed women have in common is….. children.
Supposedly these are the findings of not just one but 6 major studies. And apparently the malaise is worldwide.
Excuse me while I wipe that silly grin off my face.
By now, you’ve probably seen the Huffington Post article by Marcus Buckingham and the Sunday column by Maureen Dowd citing the long-term studies that “prove” these facts. Of course, a lot of women simply don’t believe it. Some just don’t like the fact that the news is being delivered by a man.
Me? I’m more interested in WHY it could be true.
Marcus covered a lot of the more obvious killjoys of modern life and he’s let most of them off the hook. We can’t blame our increasing sulkiness on the fact that we now have jobs AND do most of the work at home. Men are sharing more equally in that burden so we should be getting happier.
Evidently it’s not because we work longer hours than men, because, according to Marcus, we don’t. The studies showed that men and women work the same number of hours each day. (I’m thinking this may have something to do with women’s definition of “work.”)
And, finally, it’s not because of gender-based stereotyping because evidently that doesn’t exist anymore. (Really? I thought I spotted some scurrying under a desk at my last corporate job. And girlfriends do whisper about sightings in their own lives.)
So, what could it be?
Interestingly enough, I think one of the answers might be right under Marcus’s nose.
Marcus’s friend Oprah did a study about 3 years ago exploring women and change. It seems we’re pretty hooked on change when we see a way to improve things in our lives or the lives of our family and community.
In short, “good enough” is not enough for women if they’ve got any control over the situation.
And it’s not because we’re malcontents. Whether it’s a new plan to get the family to sit down at the table for dinner, or a personal re-invention project that includes creating a more meaningful career and saving a species, women are almost continuously in the process of changing some part of their world for the better.
“But change is good! Why would that add to our unhappiness?” you’re probably wondering. And you’re right. Heck, back when there were only a few areas of our lives that we had any control over, it was probably satisfying to strive. To change. To make EVERYTHING better.
But now, so many things are broken. And, theoretically, we have the power to fix them all.
If only we had the time.
Feeling a singular responsibility for constant improvement is a theme I’ve certainly seen over 20 years of interviewing thousands of women about everything from exercise and health to blue jeans and toothpaste. It’s just that I always saw it as one of our strengths.
I’d still like to think that it is. It would make me so happy.